Utica First Insurance 401(k) match, vesting and fees
What Utica First Insurance's 401(k) plan says about matching contributions
Plan features
Match, vesting and enrollment details have not been published from this plan's audit report yet. The figures below come from the structured filing.
| Recordkeeper | Principal Life Insurance Company | Schedule C ↗ |
| Independent auditor | Buffamante Whipple Buttafaro, P.C. (unmodified opinion, limited scope) | Schedule H ↗ |
| Plan type and status | 401(k) · Active | Form 5500 ↗ |
| Late participant contributions | Reported on the filing | Schedule H ↗ |
How the plan compares
Plan year 2024 medians for 3,409 defined-contribution plans in finance and insurance with 100 to 499 participants.
| Utica First Insurance: employer contribution per participant | $5,237 | |
| Peer median | $2,868 |
| Utica First Insurance: average balance | $159,266 | |
| Peer median | $95,281 |
| Utica First Insurance: admin expenses ÷ assets | 0.55% | |
| Peer median | 0.22% |
Admin expenses are the plan's reported administrative expenses divided by its assets; they do not include fund expense ratios.
Plan history
Plan assets went from $22.5M at the end of plan year 2021 to $25.3M at the end of plan year 2024.
| Plan year | Participants | Assets | Employer contributions | Per participant | Admin expense ratio | Match formula | Filing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | 160 | $25.3M | $833K | $5,237 | 0.55% | Not published | Form 5500 ↗ |
| 2023 | 152 | $22.4M | $756K | $4,971 | 0.52% | Not published | Form 5500 ↗ |
| 2022 | 144 | $19M | $681K | $4,867 | 0.52% | Not published | Form 5500 ↗ |
| 2021 | 133 | $22.5M | $638K | $4,836 | 0.54% | Not published | Form 5500 ↗ |
Common questions
Does Utica First Insurance match 401(k) contributions?
The match terms for the Utica First Insurance Company Employees Retirement & Savings Plan have not been published from its filing yet. The plan year 2024 filing reports $833K in employer contributions, about $5,237 per participant. That total includes any match and profit-sharing; it is not a match formula.
When is the Utica First Insurance 401(k) match vested?
The vesting schedule for the Utica First Insurance Company Employees Retirement & Savings Plan is not in the data published so far. Your Summary Plan Description states it.
Who manages the Utica First Insurance 401(k)?
The recordkeeper listed on Schedule C of the plan year 2024 filing is Principal Life Insurance Company. The plan administrator is Utica First Insurance Company.
I left Utica First Insurance. How do I find my old 401(k)?
Your account stays in the plan until you move it. Contact the plan administrator (Utica First Insurance Company, (315) 736-8211) or the recordkeeper, Principal Life Insurance Company. The Utica First Insurance old 401(k) page lists the contacts from every plan filing. Find an old Utica First Insurance 401(k)
Data from the public Form 5500 annual reports Utica First Insurance filed with the U.S. Department of Labor (plan years 2021 and 2022 and 2023 and 2024) and, where noted, the attached independent auditor's report. Plan terms may have changed since the filing; check your current Summary Plan Description. PlanFacts is not affiliated with Utica First Insurance. Not financial advice. Report a correction · Methodology